Console Monster News
DICE: Battlefield 3 players can't shoot civilians

DICE has confirmed that Battlefield 3 players won't be able to shoot civilians.

Speaking to RockPaperShotgun, executive producer, Patrick Bach, said the decision was made because the studio didn't want the game to become the subject of controversy.

Bach said: "If you put the player in front of a choice where they can do good things or bad things, they will do bad things, go dark side - because people think it's cool to be naughty, they won't be caught.

"In a game where it's more authentic, when you have a gun in your hand and a child in front of you what would happen? Well the player would probably shoot that child. We would be the ones to be blamed. We have to build our experiences so we don't put the player in experiences where they can do bad things.

"Me personally, I'm trying to stay away from civilians in games like BF because I think people will do bad. I don't want to see videos on the internet where people shoot civilians. That's something I will sanitise by removing that feature from the game.

"We are trying to do something that is more mature. Mature not being gore - some people confuse the two. That's childish actually, to want more blood."

Do you agree with Bach’s thoughts? Leave us a comment with your thoughts.

Support Console Monster by purchasing Battlefield 3 from Shopto.net. CLICK HERE and we will be taken to the game's page at Shopto.net where you can buy or pre-order this game today! Or buy from a selection of other online retailers listed on the right side of this page.
3 months ago
0
Battlefield 3 - End Game Launch Trailer
Bad a ba ba ba, bad a ba ba ba
4 months ago
0
Battlefield 3 - End Game DLC Capture Flag Gameplay
We've added the latest media for Battlefield 3, available for the Xbox 360 and PS3.
6 months ago
0
Battlefield 3 - Aftermath Launch Trailer
The latest BF3 DLC pack is ready to roll out!
7 months ago
0
Battlefield 3 - Aftermath Premiere Trailer
Feel the Aftermath in this new trailer

Community Comments
#1 Scrips  Console Guide Pro App 15:08 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
Not sure I agree but I understand.
#2 RyanTheHamilton  Console Guide Pro App 15:21 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
Yeah
#3 Aer0Smith360  Console Guide Pro App 15:50 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
Is that nt the whole point of creating a game where it's nt ACTUALLY real...if it's that much of an issue just make the civilians nt shootable when firing or exploring the game? Why is this even news?
#4 H8XME  Console Guide Pro App 15:54 31 Aug 2011 GMT  

LLUB
#5 Rory  Console Guide Pro App 16:13 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
As long as my copy works and arrives I really do not care about unimportant details
#6 Sith Squirrell  Console Guide Pro App 16:30 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
Makes sence really no Russian was an awful level...
#7 Industryhater  Console Guide Pro App 17:33 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
I agree with #1
#8 TomTheDiver  Console Guide Pro App 18:44 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
I think it ultimately does make the game more realistic. In reality a soldier's foremost priority is to be aware of and to protect civilians.
Making it impossible to distort or twist that situation is a novel idea.
Plus, I'm sure the enemy forces can still be blown to bits. ;)
#9 dashowIroll  Console Guide Pro App 19:06 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
dont know why they would write about this
#10 one sly fox  Console Guide Pro App 19:21 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
Wouldn't it be better to leave realism in the game and let the programmer develop consequence to the players actions?
#11 one sly fox  Console Guide Pro App 19:33 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
After all, mistakes happen in war, and to take that out is simply censorship.
#12 Chatburger  Console Guide Pro App 20:33 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
It's just common sense. With all the finger pointing going on these days im surprised it was even considered.
#13 ybuy  Console Guide Pro App 20:41 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
What if a civilian picks up a gun... Then what? I'll bet they didn't think of that one!
#14 Burnt fanny  Console Guide Pro App 20:48 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
Think it's stupid really the civilians should interact with gunfire bcas it's more realistic and would give the game a sence of raw feel to modern day society if the critics want to Complain about it then let them just put a 18 certificate on the game case then they can't touch the developers I wont be shooting them anyway unless there in my crossfire bcas I'd wana win the game not bother about pointless civilians if a person gets caught in the crossfire it will look awesome not like cod yeah let's just make a bunch of guys walk thru an airport and slayer innocent people now that's a bit to much people mistake computer games to be playable by all ages wether there rated or not but if it's an 18 then don't let a 12 year old kid play the ####ing thing bcas games can be very violent!
#15 banis97  Console Guide Pro App 21:18 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
Does anyone actually cares about this detail?
#16 Lea Keytap  Console Guide Pro App 21:24 31 Aug 2011 GMT  
...nope...
#17 ThaArsonist  Console Guide Pro App 00:22 01 Sep 2011 GMT  
WTF is the game made for 3 year olds
#18 Brutal  Console Guide Pro App 00:25 01 Sep 2011 GMT  
I'm with ThaArsonist on this one.
#19 DylnCox  Console Guide Pro App 04:17 01 Sep 2011 GMT  
-1 on the realism scale. Ball up Dice, companies like Bohemia Interactive have civilians that can be gunned down. In real life combat you don't know who is real and who is civilian. I thought this game was rated mature? Grow some and add it, break away from the norm.
#20 Pogopat  Console Guide Pro App 06:15 01 Sep 2011 GMT  
Why put civ's in the game anyway? If they left this out altogether it wouldn't be a problem.
#21 Knighthawk108  Console Guide Pro App 14:09 01 Sep 2011 GMT  
I dont kno y this is news, but, on the other hand, if we could shoot civs then the british media (cant speak for any other countries media) wuld cause a s**tstorm over it, and dice wuld have alot of crap to deal with over nothing.
#22 Hobs  Console Guide Pro App 23:42 01 Sep 2011 GMT  
It's a GAME for Christ sake, your not shooting anybody.
#23 Jyat  Console Guide Pro App 01:13 02 Sep 2011 GMT  
Can I still kill enemy civilians?
#24 TheHunger  Console Guide Pro App 04:24 02 Sep 2011 GMT  
#14 Have you not heard of punctuation? Talk about a wall of words!
As for the topic, I think that no child civilians should be visible.
Adult civilians should run for cover.
Shooting a civilian gets you pulled from the action. Simples.
#25 Burnt fanny  Console Guide Pro App 04:47 02 Sep 2011 GMT  
#24 who are you an English teacher who gives a ***** always gotta be some little mug trying to start somthing why don't ya grow up u really think I care about false stops and *****
#26 ghamfroD  Console Guide Pro App 16:59 05 Sep 2011 GMT  
Poor gaming ethic from dice..
Old Comments have been stopped, but you can carry on this discussion by logging in and commenting below
Sign-up in our forums or purchase our Console Guide Mobile App to comment
News From Other Sites