Xbox Live Top 10

[damien©]

1 Call of Duty 2
2 Ghost Recon 3
3 Chromehounds
4 Oblivion
5 Battlefield 2: Modern Combat
6 Lord of the Rings: BFME2
7 Final Fantasy XI
8 Prey
9 Project Gotham Racing 3
10 Lord of the Rings: BFME2 Demo

I think this list should be for Online Play Only...

As Xbox Live Service can easily tell whether you are playing Online or Offline, I think it's giving a Skewed results of the Xbox Live Service as Oblivion is in Fourth and that has no Online Service what so ever.

So what percentage of people playing Call of Duty 2 where actually playing it Online in Multiplayer Mode instead of the Single Player Campaign.
Your Thoughts

[linkofhyrule]

Yeah, and demos shouldn't really count either.

Definitely right about how it should work, of course Call of Duty and GRAW are gonna be played more. For Oblivion though it isn't horrible.. there's a ton of stuff to play in that.

[rydo-uk]

My list couldnt even be that big lol ive only played like 8 360 games lol...

[damien©]

Yeah, and demos shouldn't really count either.

Yea just spotted that... they shouldn't even be on it.

Granted as a little fact that they might want to drop in...

"If Demo's were allowed in the List, you might be surprised to know that Lord of the Rings would have came Tenth"

or

"If we were allowed Offline Games, Oblivion would have been in Fourth"

But I think it's a misrepresentation of what people are Playing on Xbox Live Servers!

[linkofhyrule]

Yeah.. if demos are gonna be ont here they should only be on till the actual game comes out. Not like LOTR with both the retail and demo versions on at once.

[backin-strachan]

Is this the Top 10 Live games played most or YOUR top 10 live games played most.

[damien©]

Is this the Top 10 Live games played most or YOUR top 10 live games played most.
No it's the Top 10 Live Games as done my Microsoft (I assume)!

[linkofhyrule]

You have to wonder if it's official actually, FFXI isn't all that popular. I'd assume it'd be under PGR3 at least..

[backin-strachan]

Yeah I was thinking PGR3 or GRAW!!!

[Mant]

The list is from MS themselves so it's pretty offical as it gets. They way it's titled is wrong as it gives people the wrong impression of what it's all about.

[Raisedbyflames]

howdo they guage it, because i bet more peopleplayed preydemo once, than are playing pdz,but thepeople playing pdz played more hours so how do they work itout

[AfroJoe]

Yeah I was thinking PGR3 or GRAW!!!

GRAW is there... I think.

I've been under the assumption that Ghost Recon 3 is GRAw... yes?

[backin-strachan]

Yeah, I called it that before it was released then seen GRAW being played on the friend List so Ive called it GRAW ever since.

I meant GRAW or PGR3 near the top:p Well GRAW is;) but PGR3